.

Measure J Moves Forward With 3-2 Vote

Over 100 student athletes and community members attended the school board meeting to hear the vote on Measure J Phases II and III.

Correction: The original version of this story said that science classroom upgrades would be completed with funds outside the Measure J bond program, when in fact, they are now planned to be funded from within the program.

At a regular meeting Thursday evening, the South San Francisco Unified School District Board of Trustees voted 3-2 to approve the Master Plan for Phases II and III of Measure J school improvements.

Vice President Phil Weise, Trustee Maurice Goodman and the student board member Alex Moreno voted to approve the plans, while Trustee Liza Normandy and President Judy Bush voted no.

The main point of contention was whether improved science classrooms should be prioritized before certain athletic facilities, such as bleachers.

In Superintendent Alejandro Hogan's presentation, science classrooms appeared “below the line” of what the current bond program could actually pay for, and would require an additional $9 million that were not accounted for in the Phases II and III plans.

“The science classrooms should go above the line,” Bush said. Her decision not to vote to approve the Master Plan also stemmed from the fact that American Disabilities Act restrooms were not fully integrated into the current bond program, and also fell “below the line.”

Normandy supported the Master Plan, but also wanted definitive plans for financing science classrooms on the table as well.

Superintendent Alejandro Hogan said that there are additional monies outside the Measure J bonds that can be used for updating science classrooms.

Normandy and Bush requested that district staff bring plans back at a future meeting with an explanation of funds that fall outside Measure J bonds, so that the board could see the whole picture before passing the Master Plan.

In the end, the board passed the plans with the condition of moving science classroom upgrades "above the line" to make certain Measure J funded them. 

Vice President Weise told Patch that some items within the Master Plan, perhaps related to athletics, would have to be rearranged or taken out in order to push the science upgrades to be higher priority. Updated plans will be presented at a future board meeting.

The reason for approving the plan, despite the fact that it does not entirely reflect the board's priorities, such as science classrooms, was that in order to move forward with earlier steps of replacing old portables, Phases II and III need to first be passed, Weise said.

Before the board voted on the Master Plan, South San Francisco High Principal Tony Limoges spoke in support of moving forward with the plans and the importance of sports facilities at schools.

“'Athletic’ makes it sound like it’s just football and soccer,” Limoges said. He said that athletic fields also function as classrooms for physical education. He also said that sports teams are key players in combating youth violence and recidivism.   

The board also approved contracts with several architects for Measure J construction projects.

Also at the meeting, district staff informed the board that they did not recommend submitting an application for the federal grant program Race to the Top.

Trustee Shirlee Hoch attended the meeting, after very sparse appearances over the last year due to illness. Hoch excused herself near the end of the meeting just before the Measure J Master Plan vote, stating that she was in “excruciating pain.”   

Please see the attached document, or download additional documents here for more details on Measure J plans.

Don't miss a beat. Sign up for the South City Patch daily newsletter |  Like South City Patch on Facebook | Follow South City Patch on Twitter | Blog for South City Patch

Taylor Wiles October 26, 2012 at 11:35 PM
Thanks for your comment, Chris. Since this was complicated, I want to clarify that Trustee Normandy did support the bulk of Phases II and III, but also wanted to see the rest of the district's funding options explained before passing them. From the meeting, it seemed as though President Bush was of a similar mind, in addition to wanting to make sure ADA restrooms were prioritized if they were needed. (Superintendent Hogan said that all restrooms are currently compliant, but that might change in the future.) So, the two who voted against the Master Plan were not against all aspects of it, but had specific concerns surrounding it.
Jim C October 27, 2012 at 12:00 AM
My recollection of the meeting is similar to yours, Taylor. I believe the only reason that Bush and Normandy voted "no" is that they didn't want it left up in the air as to where the additional funds for the science classrooms would come from. As happy as I am that the high schools will be getting their athletic fields upgraded, I can't blame them for that. As I've said elsewhere, I wasn't aware that "Yeah, but..." was a voting option. I believe Superintendent Hogan's point about the restrooms is that they are currently compliant, but if we start to make ANY changes to them, we would have to bring them up to the new standards dictated by the ADA.
Beth Orofino October 28, 2012 at 03:02 AM
Is this vote legal? I didn't know that a student representative, who is not an officially elected Board member, could vote on matters like this. I thought his/her position was advisory. Maybe I am wrong, but I think there could be questions about the legality of this vote.
Jim C October 28, 2012 at 07:16 AM
Hi Beth! You are absolutely correct. I looked it up in the board bylaws and the student vote doesn't count. Hopefully, AT THE NEXT MEETING, Superintendent Hogan will bring a plan to the board that includes the science labs and this will be passed legally. The board as a whole should be embarrassed by this failure to understand their own rules.
Beth Orofino October 28, 2012 at 08:38 AM
Maybe it is best to look beyond any possible finger-pointing and embarrassment, and simply to focus on what is best for the kids, all 9,000 or so of them. This is always the proper bottom line. However, it takes a healthy amount of detachment and clear thinking to be successful at this.
Jim C October 28, 2012 at 06:46 PM
I guess I would argue that a little bit of embarrassment, if it helps the board get their act together, is good for the kids in the long run. Either way, you are correct, it's about the kids.
Taylor Wiles October 29, 2012 at 04:46 PM
Beth and Jim C, you're right that the student's vote did not count. The superintendent announced that this morning. That makes last week's vote 2-2. There will be another vote with a revised Master Plan on Nov. 8. Thanks for your comments.
Eric Jacobson October 29, 2012 at 10:51 PM
I just hope that they can move forward on November 8th, and include both phases for both high school fields. Many people will be upset if the new plan leaves out the phase II for El Camino's Field which includes the new Bleachers which will meet ADA standards. It would make no sense to put in a new turf field, and a all-weather track, without the bleachers. Our current bleachers are unsafe, and the new field and track will be destroyed by the heavy equipment needed to constuct the bleachers for both home, and visitors fans. It will also cost less in the long run if they have Phase II for the field done while the construction companies are here for the field and track. I hope the new plan includes the science labs, and both Phases (I / II) of the field projects. If so I do not see any reason for it not to pass 4-0. I have been at every School Board Meeting in the last year, and will continue to do so until this project is passed. I am hopeful that we can end the suspense, and give the kids of the SSFUSD a safe athletic facility. COLT PRIDE

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something