New Jail Concerns: Budget Over Safety?

A state rule bars the legislature from considering new laws that add to the prison population. Does this rule put the community at risk?


As construction crews begin to build in Redwood City, some residents are concerned that San Mateo County leadership is prioritizing money over public safety. 

In 2007, with California prisons facing an overcrowding crisis, the Senate Public Safety Committee began a policy known as “Receivership/Overcrowding Crisis Aggravation,” known as ROCA.

ROCA is an informal policy that prevents the committee from considering any legislation that would increase the prison population.

San Mateo County District Attorney Steve Wagstaffe says ROCA can hinder efforts to address important criminal issues.

“Money rather than justice is driving things,” said Wagstaffe.

Wagstaffe explains that since 2007, only high-profile cases brought to the attention of the media can lead to an exception to that rule.

One such example is Chelsea’s Law, signed by Governor Schwarzenegger in 2010 in response to the case of Chelsea King, a teenager killed by a sex offender. The law stated that anyone convicted of certain against children would receive life in prison without parole. Though the law increased the prison population, an exception was made by way of an offset of releasing other prisoners.

Wagstaffe expressed concern that in other less sensational cases, such as the issue of elder abuse, ROCA prevents effective action from being done to curb the problem. In the 1990s before the prison overcrowding situation, Wagstaffe says, bills addressing elder abuse would likely have easily passed.

Oakland Senator Loni Hancock, the current Chair of the Public Safety Committee, has continued the policy set by her predecessors, according to her Chief of Staff Hans Hermann.

Hermann insists that though the situation is unfortunate, crime rates have dropped since 2007, casting doubt upon the idea that safety is at risk from limiting the inmate population.

Carlos Alcala, spokesperson for San Francisco Assemblyman Tom Ammiano, expressed concern over the value of prison in reducing crime.

“We have found over the years that adding to the prison population has not made society safer.”

Alcala added that the ban on increasing the prison population may have the potential benefit, in the eyes of Assemblyman Ammiano, of encouraging greater emphasis on rehabilitation and other more effective punishments.

Do you think it will? 

Jim C August 13, 2012 at 07:23 PM
“We have found over the years that adding to the prison population has not made society safer.” - What a ridiculous thing to say. You can't "find" that. It is impossible to do a study that isolates that variable. And it flies in the face of common sense. If you take a habitual criminal who would commit, say, 2 crimes a year and put him in jail for a year, that's 2 crimes that didn't get committed that year. My guess is that the reason the statistics make it look like prison doesn't make society "safer" is that more and more kids are being brought up by lousy parents in lousy neighborhoods to think that criminal activity and violent behavior are normal and/or OK.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something